The Writer’s Guide to Interpreting the Lies of your Lovers and Friends

All of your friends are liars. So am I and–hopefully–so are you.

Lying can be a lovely and loving thing to do. The trick is finding the proper code to translate.

Lying can be a lovely and loving thing to do. The trick is finding the proper code to translate.

I mean this, of course, in the very best way. One of the great duties of friendship is to lie, lie well, and lie often.

We must like what our friends produce more than we would like the same thing produced by a stranger.

We must encourage what’s good in their efforts and support them when they take risks.

We must have trouble seeing their flaws and eagerly overestimate their virtues.

Indeed, one of the marks of good friends is that they go through life with a giant unexamined positive bias in your favor.

However, this makes our friends tremendously unreliable when it comes to critiquing what we do.  Even the most honest and rigorous critics among them are not to be fully trusted. They will give us the benefit of the doubt and very actively seek ways to see the best in our work. And the closer our friends are to us, the more distorted their opinions will be.

Unfortunately, before you’re a fabulously acclaimed, widely recognized author, it’s going to be hard to get anyone but your friends to look at your work. This is one of the major reasons why finding a good critique group–one that includes distant acquaintances and even strangers–should be understood as an absolute necessity for anyone who wishes to take their development as a writer seriously.

(Of course, we should also keep in mind that many critique groups are riddled with lousy critics. Learning how to recognize and discount the bad ones will be the topic of another post.)

However, even if you do have a rigorous critique group, your friends will still be a very important early audience for your work and you should develop some strategies for sorting through their most lovely and alluring lies.

When is a dollar not worth a dime?

One of the first things you can do is recognize that critiques are like cash, but everyone pays in a different denomination. A stranger discovering and enjoying your work might offer you gold bullion, whereas a distant acquaintance dispenses euros, a close friend pays in pennies, and your mother buries you in monopoly money.

currenciesYou must, therefore, develop the wits of a skillful trader who’s constantly looking at socio-political conditions around the globe to determine the true value of each and every nation’s currency.

Your best friend loving your work might be equivalent to another close friend really liking your work, which would be equivalent to a mere acquaintance being entertained, and a stranger experiencing only the mildest of amusement.

And–of course–there’s the whole issue of tastes and preferences to be considered. People who read a lot in your genre have opinions that should trade at a much higher exchange rate than those who’ve never read anything like what you write.

And finally, one must allow for inflation. Specifically, how much is your evident desire to hear something positive shaping what your friends are saying? If you respond well to criticism and always reward your friends’ honesty, you’ve probably got a sound economy going. If you tend to clam up, get pissy, or overreact then you might be more like a military junta just after a coup. The good money’ll go running and you’ll be stuck in a hyperinflationary spiral of doom.

The point is, if you don’t apply the appropriate discounting to each of the reactions you receive, you’ll likely delude yourself into pushing junk on the world and being endlessly disappointed when it flops. By the same token, if you overly discount everything you’re told (as some writers are wont to do), you’ll never get your work out at all and lose the opportunity to make a positive impact on others.

So what’s the secret to developing an accurate accounting?

Two Keys to Interpretation

Perhaps the most reliable indicator of how much your friends like your work is not what they say to you, but how much they talk about your work, or share it when you’re not looking. Actions are gold, words are paper.

The other worthy medium of exchange is the unsolicited suggestion for improvement.

A well thought out suggestion shows engagement with your work and gives you an opportunity to directly evaluate the actual content of what your beloved critic is offering. If you can instantly recognize the rightness of their point, you’ve been given something of tremendous worth and should put it to use immediately. That said, even if you disagree with their suggestion, you can at least learn that your work isn’t quite where it needs to be, and judge based on the specifics of their suggestion how far off the mark you are and in what areas.

UPDATE: This post originally had a little example about the trials and travails of producing some videos to support a Kickstarter campaign. Ultimately, I pulled down the video from YouTube, so I’ve also edited this post. A future post will describe the whole merry adventure in further detail.

3 thoughts on “The Writer’s Guide to Interpreting the Lies of your Lovers and Friends

  1. You know me. And fortunately, I know me. SO I have a few friends and relatives who have been given the literal and specific instruction, “LOVE MY WRITING.” Does this mean I am less inclined to feel the warm glow of their compliments? No. It means I can face the other “real” critiques with a bit of armor. Someone loves everything I write – so now I’ll see what the rest of the world says.
    Ummm, I know you’re saying a lot more than that, but I thought I’d share 🙂

    • Hey Mardra,

      I totally get the desire for armor and hope it will always serve you well! Indeed, I kind of envy you for it. I have the unfortunate tendency to always discount (often overly so) the nice things my closest friends say. Such a tricky thing to get right and all I know is that I’m far from good at any of it.

      -A

  2. I just saw this blog..I don’t know how I missed it! But Aaron, I 100% agree. I get nothing out of “oh, it’s fabulous,” especially when I know it’s not. I like concrete feedback letting me know where the holes are and where I can fix it. But every now and then, a little nugget of fabulousness helps take the sting out of the rest 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s